The local-global conjecture for Apollonian circle packings is false

Abstract

In a primitive integral Apollonian circle packing, the curvatures that appear must fall into one of six or eight residue classes modulo $24$. The local-global conjecture states that every sufficiently large integer in one of these residue classes appears as a curvature in the packing. We prove that this conjecture is false for many packings, by proving that certain quadratic and quartic families are missed. The new obstructions are a property of the thin Apollonian group (and not its Zariski closure), and are a result of quadratic and quartic reciprocity, reminiscent of a Brauer-Manin obstruction. Based on computational evidence, we formulate a new conjecture.