Translator Disclaimer
December, 1969 On Bartlett's Test and Lehmann's Test for Homogeneity of Variances
Nariaki Sugiura, Hisao Nagao
Ann. Math. Statist. 40(6): 2018-2032 (December, 1969). DOI: 10.1214/aoms/1177697282


The purpose of this paper is to compare a modified likelihood ratio test (Bartlett [2]) with the asymptotically UMP invariant test (Lehmann [8]) for testing homogeneity of variances of $k$ normal populations. We denote these tests by the "$M$ test" and "$L$ test," respectively. The $M$ test has been investigated by many authors, whereas the $L$ test has not. Fitting beta type distributions, Mahalanobis [9] and Nayer [11] computed the percentage points of $M$, when the numbers of observations in each sample are the same. Nayer's results were confirmed by Bishop and Nair [3], using the exact null distribution of $M$ in a form of infinite series derived by Nair [10]. Asymptotic series expansion of the null distribution of $M$ was obtained by Hartley [6], using Mellin inversion formula, from which tables for percentage points were calculated by Thompson and Merrington [16], without assuming the equality of $k$-sample sizes. Later in a more general formulation, Box [4] derived the asymptotic series expansions of the null distributions of many test statistics, including that of the $M$ test, by using the characteristic function. Recently Pearson [12] obtained some approximate powers of the $M$ test both by fitting a gamma type distribution to the inverse of the modified likelihood ratio statistic and by using the Monte Carlo method. No attempt was made, however, to investigate the asymptotic non-null distribution of $M$. Sugiura [18] has shown the limiting distribution of $M$ in multivariate case under fixed alternative hypothesis to be normal. In Section 2 of this paper we shall show that the $L$ test is not unbiased, though the $M$ test is known to be unbiased (Pitman [14], Sugiura and Nagao [19]). In Section 3, we shall derive the limiting distributions of $L$ and $M$ under sequences of alternative hypothesis with arbitrary rate of convergence to the null hypothesis as sample sizes tend to infinity. Limiting distributions are characterized by $\chi^2$, noncentral $\chi^2$, and normal distributions, according to the rate of convergence of the sequence. In Section 4, asymptotic expansion of the null distribution of $L$ is given in terms of $\chi^2$-distributions, and asymptotic formulas for the percentage points of $L$ and $M$ are obtained by using the general inverse expansion formula of Hill and Davis [7], with some numerical examples. In Section 5, asymptotic expansions of the non-null distributions of $L$ and $M$ under a fixed alternative hypothesis are derived in terms of normal distribution function and its derivatives, from which approximate powers are computed. It may be remarked that the limiting non-null distributions of $L$ and $M$ degenerate at the null hypothesis, by which asymptotic null distributions cannot be derived.


Download Citation

Nariaki Sugiura. Hisao Nagao. "On Bartlett's Test and Lehmann's Test for Homogeneity of Variances." Ann. Math. Statist. 40 (6) 2018 - 2032, December, 1969.


Published: December, 1969
First available in Project Euclid: 27 April 2007

zbMATH: 0197.44601
MathSciNet: MR260097
Digital Object Identifier: 10.1214/aoms/1177697282

Rights: Copyright © 1969 Institute of Mathematical Statistics


Vol.40 • No. 6 • December, 1969
Back to Top