Statistical Science

Causality and Association: The Statistical and Legal Approaches

K. Mengersen, S. A. Moynihan, and R. L. Tweedie

Full-text: Open access

Abstract

This paper discusses different needs and approaches to establishing “causation” that are relevant in legal cases involving statistical input based on epidemiological (or more generally observational or population-based) information.

We distinguish between three versions of “cause”: the first involves negligence in providing or allowing exposure, the second involves “cause” as it is shown through a scientifically proved increased risk of an outcome from the exposure in a population, and the third considers “cause” as it might apply to an individual plaintiff based on the first two. The population-oriented “cause” is that commonly addressed by statisticians, and we propose a variation on the Bradford Hill approach to testing such causality in an observational framework, and discuss how such a systematic series of tests might be considered in a legal context.

We review some current legal approaches to using probabilistic statements, and link these with the scientific methodology as developed here. In particular, we provide an approach both to the idea of individual outcomes being caused on a balance of probabilities, and to the idea of material contribution to such outcomes.

Statistical terminology and legal usage of terms such as “proof on the balance of probabilities” or “causation” can easily become confused, largely due to similar language describing dissimilar concepts; we conclude, however, that a careful analysis can identify and separate those areas in which a legal decision alone is required and those areas in which scientific approaches are useful.

Article information

Source
Statist. Sci., Volume 22, Number 2 (2007), 227-254.

Dates
First available in Project Euclid: 27 September 2007

Permanent link to this document
https://projecteuclid.org/euclid.ss/1190905520

Digital Object Identifier
doi:10.1214/07-STS234

Mathematical Reviews number (MathSciNet)
MR2408960

Zentralblatt MATH identifier
1246.62228

Keywords
Statistical causation epidemiological risk relative risk legal causation tort negligence admissible evidence

Citation

Mengersen, K.; Moynihan, S. A.; Tweedie, R. L. Causality and Association: The Statistical and Legal Approaches. Statist. Sci. 22 (2007), no. 2, 227--254. doi:10.1214/07-STS234. https://projecteuclid.org/euclid.ss/1190905520


Export citation

References

  • Antman, K. and Aisner, J., eds. (1987). Asbestos-Related Malignancy. Grane and Stratton, Orlando, FL.
  • Berger, M. A. (2000). The Supreme Court's trilogy on admissibility of expert testimony. In Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence, 2nd ed. 9--38. Federal Judicial Center, Washington. Available at www.fjc.gov/library/fjc_catalog.nsf.
  • Breslow, N. E. and Day, N. E. (1980). Statistical Methods in Cancer Research 1. IARC, Lyon.
  • Carruth, R. S. and Goldstein, B. D. (2001). Relative risk greater than two in proof of causation in toxic tort litigation. Jurimetrics 41 195--209.
  • Carver, T. (2004). Causation and Queensland's civil liability act. Queensland Lawyer 24 189--195.
  • Chalmers, T. C. (1991). Problems induced by meta-analysis. Statist. Med. 10 971--980.
  • Chase, G. R., Kotin, P., Crump, K. and Mitchell, R. S. (1985). Evaluation for compensation of asbestos exposed individuals. II. Apportionment of risk for lung cancer and mesothelioma. J. Occupational Medicine 27 189--198.
  • Cockburn, T. and Carver, T. (2004). Determining causation under the Civil Liability Act (Qld) 2003. Proctor 24(6) 15--18.
  • Cornfield, J. et al. (1959). Smoking and lung cancer: Recent evidence and a discussion of some questions. J. National Cancer Institute 22 173--203.
  • Cox, D. R. (1992). Causality: Some statistical aspects. J. Roy. Statist. Soc. Ser. A 155 291--301.
  • Doll, R. (1985). Occupational cancer: A hazard for epidemiologists. Internat. J. Epidemiology 14 22--31.
  • Doll, R. (2002). Proof of causality: Deduction from epidemiological observation. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 45 499--515.
  • Doll, R. and Peto, R. (1978). Cigarette smoking and bronchial carcinoma: Dose and time relationships among regular smokers and lifelong non-smokers. J. Epidemiology and Community Health 32 303--313.
  • Epa Draft Review (1990). Health Effects of Passive Smoking: Assessment of Lung Cancer in Adults and Respiratory Disorders in Children. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington.
  • Epa Review (1992). Health Effects of Passive Smoking: Assessment of Lung Cancer in Adults and Respiratory Disorders in Children. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington.
  • Feinstein, A. R. (1985). Clinical Epidemiology: The Architecture of Clinical Research. Saunders, Philadelphia.
  • Fleming, J. G. (1989). Probabilistic causation in tort law. The Canadian Bar Review 68 661--681.
  • Freckelton, I. R. and Selby, H. (2006). Expert Evidence: Law, Practice, Procedure and Advocacy. Lawbook, Pyrmont, N. S. W.
  • Garfinkel, L., Auerbach, O. and Joubert, L. (1985). Involuntary smoking and lung cancer: A case-control study. J. National Cancer Institute 75 463--469.
  • Gastwirth, J. L. (1988). Statistical Reasoning in Law and Public Policy 2. Academic Press, Boston.
  • Gastwirth, J. L. (2003). The need for careful evaluation of epidemiological evidence in product liability cases: A reexamination of Wells v Ortho and Key Pharmaceuticals. Law, Probability and Risk 2 151--189.
  • Greenland, S. (1999). Relation of the probability of causation to relative risk and doubling dose: A methodologic error that has become a social problem. Amer. J. Public Health 89 1166--1169.
  • Greenland, S. and Robins, J. (1988). Conceptual problems in the definition and interpretation of attributable fractions. Amer. J. Epidemiology 128 1185--1197.
  • Gross, A. J. (1993). Does exposure to second-hand smoke increase lung cancer risk? Chance 6(4) 11--14.
  • Hammond, E. C., Selikoff, I. J. and Seidman, H. (1979). Asbestos exposure, cigarette smoking and death rates. Ann. New York Acad. Sci. 330 473--490.
  • Hart, H. L. A. and Honoré, T. (1985). Causation in the Law, 2nd ed. Clarendon Press, Oxford.
  • Hatch, O. G. (1983). The Radiogenic Cancer Compensation Act. Congressional Record 128.
  • Hedges, L. V. and Olkin, I. (1985). Statistical Methods for Meta-Analysis. Academic Press, New York.
  • Heydon, J. D. (2004). Cross on Evidence, 7th ed. Lexis-Nexis Butterworths, Sydney.
  • Hill, A. B. (1965). The environment and disease: Association or causation? Proc. Roy. Soc. Medicine 58 295--300.
  • Hill, A. B. (1971). Principles of Medical Statistics, 9th ed. Oxford Univ. Press, New York.
  • Hirayama. T. (1981). Non-smoking wives of heavy smokers have a higher risk of lung cancer: A study from Japan. British Medical J. 282 183--185.
  • Hirayama, T. (1984). Lung cancer in Japan: Effects of nutrition and exposure to ETS. In Lung Cancer: Causes and Preventions 175--195. Verlag Chemie Weinheim.
  • Hughes, J. M., Weill, H. and Hammad, Y. Y. (1987). Mortality of workers employed in two asbestos cement plants. British J. Industrial Medicine 44 161--174.
  • Kronmal, R. A., Whitney, C. W. and Mumford, S. D. (1991). The intrauterine device and pelvic inflammatory disease: The Women's Health Study reanalyzed. J. Clinical Epidemiology 44 109--122.
  • Lagakos, S. W. and Mosteller, F. (1986). Assigned shares in compensation for radiation-related cancers. Risk Analysis 6 345--357.
  • Law of negligence Review Panel (2002). Review of the Law of Negligence. Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
  • Lee, N. C., Rubin, G. L. and Borucki, R. (1988). The intrauterine device and pelvic inflammatory disease revisited: New results from the Women's Health Study. Obstetrics and Gynecology 72 1--6.
  • Lee, P. N. (1988). Misclassification of Smoking Habits and Passive Smoking: A Review of the Evidence. Springer, Berlin.
  • Lee, P. N. (1992). Environmental Tobacco Smoke and Mortality. Karger, Basel.
  • MacMahon, B., Yen, S., Trichopoulos, D., Warren, K. and Nardi, G. (1981). Coffee and cancer of the pancreas. New England J. Medicine 304 630--633.
  • Maldonado, G. and Greenland, S. (2002). Estimating causal effects. Internat. J. Epidemiology 31 422--429.
  • Mantel, N. (1990). What is the epidemiologic evidence for a passive smoking--lung cancer association? In Indoor Air Quality. Proc. International Conference on Indoor Air Quality (H. Kasuga, ed.) 341--347. Springer, Berlin.
  • McGlone, F. and Stickley, A. (2005). Australian Torts Law. LexisNexis Butterworths, Chatswood, N.S.W.
  • Mittal, Y. (1991). Homogeneity of subpopulations and Simpson's paradox. J. Amer. Statist. Assoc. 86 167--172.
  • Mosteller, F. and Chalmers, T. (1992). Some progress and problems in meta-analysis of clinical trials. Statist. Sci. 7 227--236.
  • Nygh, P. E. and Butt, P., eds. (1998). Butterworths Concise Australian Legal Dictionary, 2nd ed. Butterworths, Sydney.
  • Peppin, P. (1991). Drug/vaccine risks: Patient decision-making and harm reduction in the pharmaceutical company duty to warn action. The Canadian Bar Review 70 473--516.
  • Price, D. (1989) Causation---the Lords' lost chance? Internat. and Comparative Law Quarterly 38 735--760.
  • Robins, J. and Greenland, S. (1989). The probability of causation under a stochastic model for individual risk. Biometrics 45 1125--1138.
  • Robins, J. and Greenland, S. (1989). Estimability and estimation of excess and etiologic fractions. Stat. Med. 8 845--859.
  • Rockette, H. E. (1993). What evidence is needed to link lung cancer and second-hand smoke? Chance 6(4) 15--18.
  • Roggli, V. L., Greenberg, S. D. and Pratt, P. C. (1992). Pathology of Asbestos-Associated Diseases. Little, Brown, Boston.
  • Rothman, K. J. (1986). Modern Epidemiology. Epidemiology Resources, Chestnut Hill, MA.
  • Rothman, K. J., ed. (1988). Causal Inference. Epidemiology Resources, Chestnut Hill, MA.
  • Rothman, K. J. and Greenland, S., eds. (1998). Modern Epidemiology, 2nd ed. Lippincott-Raven, Philadelphia.
  • Rothman, K. J. and Greenland, S. (2005). Causation and causal inference in epidemiology. Amer. J. Public Health 95 S144--S150.
  • Schuck, P. H. (1986). Agent Orange on Trial: Mass Toxic Disasters in the Courts. Belknap Press of Harvard Univ. Press, Cambridge, MA.
  • Slud, E. and Byar, D. (1988). How dependent causes of death can make risk factors appear protective. Biometrics 44 265--269.
  • Sobol, R. B. (1991). Bending the Law: The Story of the Dalkon Shield Bankruptcy. Univ. Chicago Press.
  • Stapleton, J. (1985). Compensating victims of diseases. Oxford J. Legal Studies 5 248--268.
  • Stapleton, J. (1988). The gist of negligence. I. Law Quarterly Review 104 213--249.
  • Stapleton, J. (2002). Lords a'leaping evidentiary gaps. Torts Law J. 10 276--305.
  • Steenland, K. and Greenland, S. (2004). Monte Carlo sensitivity analysis and Bayesian analysis of smoking as an unmeasured confounder in a study of silica and lung cancer. Amer. J. Epidemiology 160 384--392.
  • Stolley, P. D. (1991). When genius errs: R. A. Fisher and the lung cancer controversy. Amer. J. Epidemiology 133 416--425.
  • Susser, M. (1988). Falsification, verification and causal inference in epidemiology: Reconsideration in the light of Sir Karl Popper's philosophy. In Causal Inference (K. J. Rothman, ed.) 33--57. Epidemiology Resources, Chestnut Hill, MA.
  • Tweedie, R. L. and Mengersen, K. (1992). Lung cancer and passive smoking: Reconciling the biochemical and epidemiological approaches. British J. Cancer 66 700--705.
  • Tweedie, R. L. and Mengersen, K. (1995). Meta-analytic approaches to dose-response relationships, with application in studies of lung cancer and exposure to environmental tobacco smoke. Stat. Med. 14 545--569.
  • Wald, N. J., Nanchahal, K., Thompson, S. G. and Cuckle, H. S. (1986). Does breathing other people's tobacco smoke cause lung cancer? British Medical J. 293 1217--1222.
  • Weed, D. L. (1988). Causal criteria and Popperian refutation. In Causal Inference (K. J. Rothman, ed.) 15--32. Epidemiology Resources, Chestnut Hill, MA.
  • Weill, H., Hughes, J. M. and Waggenspack, C. (1979). Influence of dose and fiber type on respiratory malignancy risk in asbestos cement manufacturing. Amer. Review Respiratory Disease 120 345--354.
  • Wraith, D. and Mengersen, K. (2007). Assessing the combined effect of asbestos exposure and smoking on lung cancer: A Bayesian approach. Stat. Med. 26 1150--1169.
  • Wu-Williams, A. H. et al. (1990). Lung cancer among women in north-east China. British J. Cancer 62 982--987.
  • Yu, B. and Gastwirth, J. (2003). The use of the `reverse Cornfield inequality' to assess the sensitivity of a non-significant association to an omitted variable. Stat. Med. 22 3383--3401.
  • Civil Liability Act 2003(Qld). (``CLA'')
  • Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
  • Federal Rules of Evidence (1975)
  • Allen v United States. D. Utah, F. Suppl. 247:588, 1984. Reversed on ground of sovereign immunity: 525 A. 2d 287 (N.J.S.C., 1987).
  • Ayers v Jackson Township (1987) 106 N.J. 557, 525 A.2d 287.
  • Batiste v State of Queensland [2002] 2 Qd R 119 at para [29].
  • Bitupave Ltd v McMahon (1999) 18 NSWCCR 481.
  • Bonnington Castings Ltd v Wardlaw [1956] AC 613.
  • Braun v Lorillard, Inc. 84 F.3d 230 (7th Cir) (1996).
  • Chappel v Hart (1998) 195 CLR 232.
  • Daubert v Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc. 509 U.S. 579 (1993).
  • D.D. v CSR Ltd & Midalco Pty Ltd Gallagher. Supreme Court WA$, 1990$.
  • Denzin & Ors v Nutrasweet & Ors [1999] NSWSC 106.
  • E M Baldwin & Son Pty Ltd v Plane (1999) Aust Torts R 81-499.
  • Fairchild v Glenhoven Funeral Services Ltd [2002] All ER (D) 139 (Jun); [2002] 3 WLR 89.
  • General Electric Co. v Joiner 522 U.S. 136 (1997).
  • Hawkinson v A.H. Robins Co., Inc., 595 F. Supp. 1290 (D. Colo. 1984).
  • Hotson v East Berkshire Area Health Authority [1987] A.C. 750; [1987] 2 All E.R. 909 (H.L.); [1987] 1 All E.R. 210 (C.A.).
  • In Re ``agent orange'' product liability litigation 597 F. Supp. 740; 1984 U.S. Dist (E.D.N.Y) 1984.
  • James Hardie & Coy Pty Ltd v Roberts (1999) 47 NSWLR 425 (CA).
  • Kumho Tire Co. v Carmichael 119 S. Ct. 1167 (1999).
  • March v Stramare (1990-1) 171 CLR 506.
  • McGhee v National Coal Board [1973] 1 WLR 1, [1972] 3 All ER 1008 (H.L).
  • R v Luttrell [2004] 2 Cr App R 31.
  • Re Joint Eastern and Southern District Asbestos Litigation 52 F 3d 1124 (2nd Cir 1995).
  • Seltsam Pty Ltd v McGuiness & Anor [2000] 49 NSWLR 262. (``Seltsam'').
  • Shorey v PT Ltd (2003) 197 ALR 410.
  • Sindell v Abbott Laboratories (1980) 26 Cal 3d 588, 607 P.2d 924 (Cal S.C.).
  • Wallaby Grip Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW (2001) 21 NSWCCR 650.
  • Westberry v Gislaved Gummi 178 F.3d 257 (1999).
  • Wilsher v Essex Health Authority [1988] 2 W.L. R. 557, [1988] 1 All E.R. 871 (H.L).
  • Ybarra v Spangard (1944) 25 Cal 2d 486, 154 P.2d 687 (Cal. S.C.).