Source: Internat. Statist. Rev. Volume 74, Number 3
(2006), 285-304.
For a target socio-economic variable, two sources of data with different precisions and collecting frequencies may be available. Typically, the less frequent data (e.g., annual report or census) are more reliable and are considered as benchmarks. The process of using them to adjust the more frequent and less reliable data (e.g., repeated monthly surveys) is called benchmarking.
In this paper, we show the relationship among three types of benchmarking methods in the literature, namely the Denton (original and modified), the regression, and the signal-extraction methods. A new method called ''quasi-linear regression'' is proposed under the multiplicative assumption. The numerical Denton method is currently widely used. The aim of this paper is to promote the other two methods which are statistically model-based; the model for the survey error is assumed to be known. Assuming the survey-error series follows an autoregressive model of order 1, by simulation, we investigate the impact of misspecification of the model on the benchmarking prediction according to the criterion of minimizing the root-mean-squared error of prediction. It is concluded that both statistical methods have great advantages over the Denton method and they are robust to misspecification of the survey-error model. The problem of how to obtain a survey-error model is also mentioned.
References
[1] Bassi, V.L. (1958). ''Appendix A''. In Economic Forecasting, Ed. V.L. Bassi. New York: McGraw-Hill.
[2] Bloem, A.M., Dippelsman, R.J. & Maehle, N.O. (2001). Quarterly National Accounts Manual: Concepts, Data Sources and Compilation. International Monetary Fund, Washington.
[3] Chen, Z.G., Cholette, P.A. & Dagum, E.B. (1996). A nonparametric method for benchmarking survey data via signal extraction. Working paper of Statistics Canada, No. BSMD-96-001E.
[4] Chen, Z.G., Cholette, P.A. & Dagum, E.B. (1997). A nonparametric method for benchmarking survey data via signal extraction. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 92, 1563-1571.
[5] Chen, Z.G. & Wu, K.H. (2005). Survey error modelling in the presence of benchmarks. Submitted for publication.
[6] Cholette, P.A. (1984). Adjusting sub-annual series to yearly benchmarks. Survey Methodology, 10, 35-49.
[7] Cholette, P.A. & Dagum, E.B. (1994). Benchmarking time series with autocorrelated survey errors. International Statistical Review, 62, 365-377.
[8] Chow, G.C. & Lin, A. (1971). Best linear unbiased interpolation, distribution and extrapolation of time series by related series. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 53, 372-375.
[9] Dagum, E.B., Cholette, P.A. & Chen, Z.G. (1998). A unified view of signal extraction benchmarking, interpolation and extrapolation of time series. International Statistical Review, 66, 245-296.
[10] Denton, F.T. (1971). Adjustment of monthly or quarterly series to annual totals: An approach based on quadratic minimization. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 66, 99-102.
[11] Durbin, J. & Quenneville, B. (1997). Benchmarking by state space models. International Statistical Review, 65, 23-48.
[12] Fernández, R.B. (1981). A methodological note on the estimation of time series. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 63, 471-476.
[13] Hillmer, S.C. & Trabelsi, A. (1987). Benchmarking of economic time series. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 82, 1064-1071.
[14] Nasse, P. (1973). Le système des comptes nationaux trimestriels. Annales de l'Insee, No.14 (September-December), 119-161.
[15] Nelson, C.R. & Plosser, C.I. (1982). Trends and random walks in macroeconomic time series. Journal of Monetary Economics, 10, 139-162.
[16] Pfeffermann, D. (1991). Estimation and seasonal adjustment of population means using data from repeated surveys. Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, 9, 163-175.
[17] Scott, A.J., Smith, T.M.F. & Jones, R.G. (1977). The application of time series methods to the analysis of repeated surveys. International Statistical Review, 45, 13-28.
[18] Trabelsi, A. & Hillmer, S.T. (1990). Bench-marking time series with reliable bench-marks. Applied Statistics (JRSS, Series C), 39, 367-379.
